Skip to main content

Free Black Charlestonians in Debate: The Complete Proceedings of the Clionian Debating Society, 1847–1858: Page 135 →— 1858 —

Free Black Charlestonians in Debate: The Complete Proceedings of the Clionian Debating Society, 1847–1858
Page 135 →— 1858 —
    • Notifications
    • Privacy
  • Project HomeFree Black Charlestonians in Debate
  • Projects
  • Learn more about Manifold

Notes

Show the following:

  • Annotations
  • Resources
Search within:

Adjust appearance:

  • font
    Font style
  • color scheme
  • Margins
table of contents
  1. Cover Page
  2. Title Page
  3. Copyright Page
  4. Contents
  5. List of illustrations
  6. Acknowledgments
  7. Introduction Performing Freedom on Slavery’s Hearth
    1. Debating as Education, Debating as Practice
    2. Free Persons of Color in Pre–Civil War Charleston
    3. Self-Governance
    4. Debates
    5. Orations
    6. Library Acquisitions
    7. Creating an Archive
    8. A Green Oasis
    9. Notes
  8. Note on transcription
    1. Notes
  9. Proceedings of the Clionian Debating Society, November 5, 1847–January 14, 1858
    1. — 1847 —
      1. Proceedings of the Clionian Debating Society. [November 9, 1847]
      2. [November 16, 1847]
      3. [November 23, 1847]
      4. [December 1, 1847]
      5. [December 8, 1847]
      6. [December 15, 1847]
      7. [December 22, 1847]
      8. Notes
    2. — 1848 —
      1. [January 5, 1848]
      2. [January 12, 1848]
      3. [January 19, 1848]
      4. [January 26, 1848]
      5. [February 2, 1848]
      6. [February 4, 1848]
      7. [February 9, 1848]
      8. [February 10, 1848]
      9. [February 16, 1848]
      10. [February 23, 1848]
      11. [March 1, 1848]
      12. [March 15, 1848]
      13. [March 22, 1848]
      14. [April 5, 1848]
      15. [May 17, 1848]
      16. [June 7, 1848]
      17. [July 19, 1848]
      18. [September 18, 1848]
      19. [October 1, 1848]
      20. [December 17, 1848]
      21. [December 19, 1848]
      22. [December 26, 1848]
      23. Notes
    3. — 1849 —
      1. Anniversary Day, January 1st 1849
      2. [January 2, 1849]
      3. [February 7, 1849]
      4. [February 15, 1849]
      5. [February 28, 1849]
      6. [March 5, 1849]
      7. [March 7, 1849]
      8. [March 14, 1849]
      9. [March 21, 1849]
      10. [March 28, 1849]
      11. [April 4, 1849]
      12. [April 11, 1849]
      13. May 21st 1849
      14. May 23rd 1849
      15. ‘CDS,’ May 30th 1849
      16. ‘CDS,’ June 6th 1849
      17. ‘CDS,’ June 20th 1849
      18. ‘CDS,’ June 27th 1849
      19. ‘CDS,’ July 5th 1849
      20. ‘CDS,’ July 10th 1849
      21. ‘CDS,’ July 12th 1849
      22. ‘CDS,’ July 25th 1849
      23. ‘CDS,’ August 1st 1849
      24. ‘CDS,’ August 8th 1849
      25. C.D.S., August 15th 1849
      26. CDS, August 22nd 1849
      27. C.D.S., August 29th 1849
      28. C.D.S., September 6th 1849
      29. ‘C.D.S.,’ September 13th 1849
      30. ‘C.D.S.,’ September 27th 1849
      31. C.D.S., October 4th 1849
      32. C.D.S., October 8th 1849
      33. “C.D.S.,” November 5th 1849
      34. ‘C.D.S.,’ December 3rd 1849
      35. “C.D.S.,” December 26th 1849
      36. Notes
    4. — 1850 —
      1. 2nd “Anniversary Celebration” C.D.S., January 1st 1850.
      2. C.D.S., January 7th 1850
      3. ‘C.D.S.,’ February 4th 1850
      4. ‘C.D.S.,’ March 4th 1850
      5. Protracted Meeting, March 11th 1850
      6. ‘C.D.S.,’ March 20th 1850
      7. ‘C.D.S.,’ March 27th 1850
      8. ‘C.D.S.,’ April 3rd 1850
      9. ‘C.D.S.,’ April 10th 1850
      10. ‘C.D.S.,’ April 17th 1850
      11. ‘C.D.S.,’ May 1st 1850
      12. ‘CDS,’ May 22nd 1850
      13. ‘CDS,’ May 29th 1850
      14. ‘C.D.S.,’ June 12th 1850
      15. ‘C.D.S.,’ June 19th 1850
      16. ‘C.D.S.,’ July 1st 1850
      17. ‘CDS,’ July 8th 1850
      18. ‘CDS,’ July 17th 1850
      19. ‘CDS,’ July 24th 1850
      20. C.D.S., July 31st 1850
      21. C.D.S., August 14th 1850
      22. ‘CDS,’ September 4th 1850
      23. ‘CDS,’ September 11th 1850
      24. ‘C.D.S.,’ September 18th 1850
      25. C.D.S., October 2nd 1850
      26. ‘CDS,’ October 14th 1850
      27. CDS, November 4th 1850
      28. C.D.S., December 2nd 1850
      29. Notes
    5. — 1851 —
      1. 3rd “Anniversary Celebration” C.D.S., January 1st 1851
      2. C.D.S., January 6th 1851
      3. C.D.S., February 3rd 1851
      4. ‘CDS,’ March 10th 1851
      5. C.D.S., March 17th 1851
      6. ‘C.D.S.,’ March 31st 1851
      7. ‘C.D.S.,’ April 14th 1851
      8. C.D.S., May 7th 1851
      9. C.D.S., June 9th 1851
      10. C.D.S., June 23rd 1851
      11. C.D.S., June 30th 1851
      12. C.D.S., July 14th 1851
      13. C.D.S., July 28th 1851
      14. C.D.S., August 11th 1851
      15. C.D.S., August 25th 1851
      16. C.D.S., September 8th 1851
      17. C.D.S., September 22nd 1851
      18. Continued Proceedings of the Clionian. Debating. Society. “Clionian Society,” September 22nd 1851
      19. Clionian D. Society, September 25th 1851
      20. Clionian D. Society, October 6th 1851
      21. “Clionian D. Society,” October 13th 1851
      22. “Clionian D. Society,” October 27th 1851
      23. “Clionian D. Society,” November 10th 1851
      24. “Clionian D. Society,” December 1st 1851
      25. “Clionian D. Society,” December 8th 1851
      26. Clionian D. Society, December 22nd 1851
      27. Clionian. D. Society, December 29th 1851
      28. Notes
    6. — 1852 —
      1. 4th Anniversary Celebration of Clionian. D. Society., January 1st 1852
      2. Clionian. D. Society, January 26th 1852
      3. Clionian. D. Society., February 23rd 1852
      4. Clionian. D. Society., March 8th 1852
      5. Clionian. D. Society., March 22nd 1852
      6. Clionian. D. Society, April 12th 1852
      7. Clionian. D. Society, April 26th 1852
      8. Clionian. D. Society, June 14th 1852
      9. “Clionian, D. Society,” June 28th/52
      10. Clionian Society, July 1st 1852
      11. “Clionian. D. Society,” July 29th 1852
      12. “Clionian. D. Society.,” September 13th 1852
      13. “Clionian. D. Society,” October 11th 1852
      14. Clionian. D. Society, October 25th 1852
      15. Clionian, D. Society, November 8th/52
      16. Clionian. D. Society, November 29th/52
      17. Clionian. D. Society., December 13th 1852
      18. Thursday Evening, December 16th [1852]
      19. Clionian. D. Society., December 30th 1852
      20. Notes
    7. — 1853 —
      1. “5th Anniversary Celebration” of Clionian. D. Society, January 10th 1853
      2. Clionian. D. Society., January 12th/53
      3. Clionian. D. Society, February 14th/53
      4. Clionian. D. Society, February 23rd/53
      5. Clionian. D. Society., March 9th 1853
      6. Clionian. D Society., March 23d/53.
      7. Clionian Society, April 14th 1853.
      8. Clionian Society, April 15th 1853.
      9. Clionian Society, April 27th/53.
      10. Clionian Society, May 11th 1853.
      11. Clionian June 8th 1853. Clionian Society.
      12. Clionian Society, June 22d 1853.
      13. Clionian Society, July 6th 1853.
      14. Clionian Society, July 20th/53.
      15. Clionian Society, August 3d/53
      16. Clionian Society, September 14th 1853.
      17. Charleston, September 16th/53.
      18. Clionian Society, September 28th/53.
      19. Clionian Society, October 12th 1853.
      20. Clionian Society, November 9th/53.
      21. Clionian Society, November 23d 1853.
      22. Clionian Society, December 7th/53
      23. Clionian Society, Decbr 21st 1853.
      24. Notes
    8. — 1854 —
      1. Sixth anniversary celebration of Clionian Debating Society., January 2d 1854.
      2. Clionian Society, February 1st 1854
      3. Clionian Society, February 14th/54.
      4. Clionian Society, March 14th 1854.
      5. Clionian Society, March 28th 1854.
      6. Clionian Society, April 25th 1854.
      7. Clionian Society, May 11th/54.
      8. Clionian Society, July 12th 1854
      9. Clionian Society, July 19th 1854
      10. Clionian Society, July 26th/54
      11. Clionian Society, August 30th/54
      12. Clionian. D. Society., Decr 6th 1854
      13. Clionian Society, December 29th/54
      14. Clionian D Society., Seventh anniversary, January 1st 1855
      15. Clionian Society, December 29th/54
      16. Notes
    9. — 1855 —
      1. Seventh Anniversary., Clionian D Society, January 1st 1855
      2. Clionian Society, January 22nd/55.
      3. Clionian Society, June 18th/55
      4. Clionian Society, July 9th/55
      5. Clionian Society, July 23rd/55
      6. Notes
    10. — 1856 —
      1. Eighth Anniversary celebration of Clionian D. Society, January 7th 1856
      2. Clionian. D. Society, February 4th/56
      3. Clionian D. Society, April 7th/56
      4. Clionian. D. Society, May 5th/56
      5. Clionian. D. Society, June 2nd/56
      6. Notes
    11. — 1857 —
      1. Clionian. D. Society, February ^2nd^ 1857
      2. Ninth Anniversary Celebration of Clionian. Debating Society, February 16th 1857
      3. Note
    12. — 1858 —
      1. Clionian. D. Society, Jany 14th/58
      2. Note
  10. Appendix A Members, Honorary Members, and Supporters
  11. Appendix B Debating Questions and Decisions
  12. Appendix C Orations
  13. Appendix D Publications Acquired for Society Library
  14. Further reading
  15. Index

Page 135 →— 1858 —

[In this year the society dissolved. A society secretary minuted one meeting. —Ed.]

Clionian. D. Society, Jany 14th/58

A special meeting of this Society was called on the evening of the above date. In the absence of the President and Vice the meeting was called to order by the next table Officer—Secretary H. Cardozo Jr. Upon motion of S. W. Beaird, Esq., Mr. Wm. E. Marshall was unanimously called to the Chair. Mr. Beaird now arose and spoke of the object that called us together—he alluded to the many difficulties and discouragements under which the Society labors, and which has so greatly crippled her efforts, and retarded her progress as to bring its members to the reluctant conclusion that her existence had better be discontinued: he also alluded in feeling terms to the matter of a dissolution—which would cause a severance of ties that had been so pleasant and profitable. After he took his seat other members in succession arose and followed in the same strain of remarks—giving expression to the solemnity and grief that pervaded their minds while considering the impossibility of continuing the existence of our much loved, and highly cherished Institution under present political disadvantages. After a full interchange of opinions and feelings a motion from H. Cardozo Jr. was unanimously adopted that the Society do now discontinue its existence.

Mr. S. W. Beaird then moved that a Committee of five be appointed to consider the best mode of effecting a dissolution—which was unanimously carried, the Chair then appointed Messrs. S. W. Beaird, R. L. Deas, C. D. Ludeke, W. O. Weston, and H. Cardozo Jr. for this purpose, who will make a report at the next meeting of the Society.1

All business being now concluded, the Society on motion adjourned.

Hy. Cardozo Jr.

Page 136 →Note

  1. 1. Simeon W. Beaird (1826–1894), who had been reared in the family of Samuel Weston after his own father died, taught a clandestine school for Black children in Charleston in the 1850s. Beaird moved to Augusta, Georgia, during the Civil War. A schoolteacher, Methodist minister, and Republican political leader, Beaird was elected to Georgia’s state constitutional convention in 1867–1868. Returning to South Carolina in the 1870s, Beaird served as county treasurer of Aiken County. He remained committed to education and religion throughout his life. See B. F. Witherspoon, “The Rev. T. [sic] W. Beaird,” Southwestern Christian Advocate, January 24, 1895, 5; and Angela G. Ray, “Warriors and Statesmen: Debate Education among Free African American Men in Antebellum Charleston,” in Speech and Debate as Civic Education, ed. J. Michael Hogan, Jessica A. Kurr, Michael J. Bergmaier, and Jeremy D. Johnson (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 2017), 25–28.

    Robert L. Deas remained in Charleston until his death of typhoid fever on April 27, 1865, at age thirty; death records listed his occupation as porter. At the time Deas was president of the Friendly Association. In 1860 he had paid tax on $1,600 worth of real estate, and he bequeathed a life interest in a house on Charlotte Street to his mother and the residue of his estate to his wife, Hannah G. Deas. He was interred in the cemetery of the Brown Fellowship Society. See “South Carolina, U.S., Death Records, 1821–1971,” Ancestry.com (online database), 2008, https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8741/; Friendly Association Records, 1853–1869, South Carolina Historical Society, Charleston, SC; Robert L. Deas, last will and testament, Will Books for Charleston County, 1790–1860, vol. 50 (1862–68), 334, South Carolina Department of Archives and History, Columbia, SC.

    Conrad D. Ludeke (1835–1895), who was an active member and sometime officer of the Friendly Association, resigned from that group in June 1860, stating his plan to leave the state and appointing Robert L. Deas to act as his agent to receive the financial allotment due him from the group’s treasury. In April 1861 Ludeke, then living in New York City, enlisted in the Union Army. During the war he served in Company B, 82nd Regiment, New York Infantry (1861), Company C, 90th Regiment, New York Infantry (1861–1863), and Company C, 1st Regiment, New Orleans Infantry (1863–1866), attaining the rank of captain and adjutant. He then worked as a clerk for the Metropolitan Police of New Orleans; in 1871 he returned to Charleston. Ludeke was married twice, first to Elizabeth Chloe Sparrow Wrigley Esmond Ludeke (m. 1864, div. 1873) and then to Julia Brennan Ludeke (m. 1874). His and Julia’s daughter, Ada L. Ludeke (1877–1932), was a schoolteacher in Charleston. Conrad D. Ludeke died on March 14, 1895. Friendly Association Records, 1853–1869; Conrad D. Ludeke, Pension Application File, Records of the Department of Veterans Affairs, 1773–1985, Record Group 15, National Archives and Records Administration, Washington, DC; Angela G. Ray, “Rhetoric and the Archive,” Review of Communication 16, no. 1 (2016): 51–56.

    William O. Weston (1832–1907), son of Methodist tailor Samuel Weston and Hannah Clark Weston, was a teacher in freedmen’s schools in postwar Charleston, along with his wife, Monimia Weston. In the late 1860s he served on Charleston’s board of aldermen and was an associate pastor at Centenary Methodist Episcopal Church, where he was remembered as “a clear and strong preacher.” See American Page 137 →Missionary Association Archives, 1839–1882, Amistad Research Center, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA; Centenary Methodist Episcopal Church Records, Avery Research Center for African American History and Culture, College of Charleston, Charleston, SC; Eric Foner, Freedom’s Lawmakers: A Directory of Black Officeholders during Reconstruction, rev. ed. (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1996), 226; and William H. Lawrence, “A Sketch of the History of the Reorganization of the South Carolina Conference, and of Centenary Church,” in The Centenary Souvenir, Containing a History of Centenary Church, Charleston, and an Account of the Life and Labors of Rev. R. V. Lawrence, Father of the Pastor of Centenary Church (Charleston, SC, 1885), xvi.

    Henry Cardozo (1830–1886) was the eldest son of Lydia Weston, who was enslaved at the time of her birth, and the Jewish merchant Isaac N. Cardozo. Married to Catherine F. McKinney Cardozo, he worked as a tailor in Cleveland, Ohio, from 1858 to 1868. Cardozo was elected to the South Carolina state senate from Kershaw County in 1870 and later presided over the board of Claflin University. He served for many years in the Methodist Episcopal Church and was pastor of Charleston’s Old Bethel in the mid- 1880s. See Minutes of the Annual Conferences of the Methodist Episcopal Church: Spring Conferences of 1887 (New York: Phillips and Hunt, 1887), 84; Claflin University and South Carolina Agricultural College and Mechanics’ Institute, Orangeburg, S.C., 1876- 77 [Orangeburg, SC, 1877]; and Foner, Freedom’s Lawmakers, 40. Please note that two individuals in the Clionian minutes are named Henry Cardozo; one joined the society in 1849, the other in 1851.

Annotate

Next Chapter
Appendix A Members, Honorary Members, and Supporters
PreviousNext
© 2025 University of South Carolina
Powered by Manifold Scholarship. Learn more at
Opens in new tab or windowmanifoldapp.org